Header Logo
About Login
← Back to all posts

The Gift and Curse of Guitar

Mar 08, 2025

Today, I want to talk about something I call "the gift and the curse." It's a phrase I use a lot when describing the guitar, because honestly, the very things that make it so amazing can also make it incredibly challenging. As always, I recommend that you watch/listen to the video over the article since it has the most detail, but you also have the article for a quick summary. 

The Gift & Curse of Guitar Part 1

But before we dive into that, let's take a quick detour. You've probably heard the story about the four-minute mile. For years, it was considered humanly impossible. Records show the first recorded mile race was in 1776, and it wasn't until 1954 that Roger Bannister finally broke that four-minute barrier. Almost 200 years of "impossible!"

Then, something incredible happened. Within months, others were doing it. Within a decade, high schoolers were regularly running sub-four-minute miles. It wasn't that humans suddenly evolved; it was that the mental barrier was broken. Once someone proved it was possible, others followed suit.

Now, let's bring this back to the guitar. The beautiful thing about our instrument is that we have endless examples of what's possible. Every genre, every style, every technique – it's all out there, inspiring us. We hear a jazz lick, a classical piece, an Indian slide riff, and we think, "Man, I want to do that!"

That's the gift. We're constantly inspired, constantly pushing our boundaries. But here's the curse: How do we organize it all? How do we practice it all? Do we need teachers? Courses? How do we balance all these diverse influences?

Think about it: If you play the French horn, you're likely focused on Western classical music. You have a clear path, a defined repertoire. But guitar? We have dozens of paths!

This week, I was reminded of this in a big way. I stumbled upon a classical guitar arrangement of Don McLean's "Starry, Starry Night (Vincent)," and it completely blew me away. I have to learn it. But then, I was in the gym listening to Monuments, and John Browne's metal playing with his unique chord voicings and harmonies just floored me. Suddenly, I'm thinking, "I need to learn eight-string dadgad metal!" And then, there's Alan Hines, whose improvisational legato playing is something I've been working on for over a year.

So, in one week, I'm juggling:

  • Classical fingerstyle: Nylon string, intricate arrangements, a whole different technique.
  • Eight-string metal: Dadgad tuning, complex harmonies, a completely different mindset.
  • Legato improvisation: Clean electric tone, improvising over changes, developing speed and fluidity.

And that's just three players! I have a whole list of others I'd love to emulate.

That's the gift and the curse. Endless inspiration, but also endless complexity. It can be overwhelming, even discouraging if you're not careful.

But here's the thing: Just like the four-minute mile, we know what's possible. We've seen it. With the right guidance, mindset, and practice, you can achieve any guitar goal.

So, if you're feeling overwhelmed, take a breath. You're not alone. Keep exploring, keep learning, and keep enjoying the beautiful, complex, and inspiring world of the guitar.

Stay tuned, keep practicing, and here's the music I discussed in the article. 

Vincent (Starry, Starry Night) by Don McLean - Danish Guitar Performance - Soren Madsen
John Browne
Allen Hinds 2.13.13 Now Really

 

 

Andre Fludd.

Why Most Guitar Lessons Fail
I’ve had thousands of private music lessons in my life: -Guitar, singing, even violin to improve my guitar. -Sometimes two or three different teachers in the same week. -And I’ve been giving private lessons myself since I was barely two years into playing. If anyone can speak to the pros and cons of one-on-one lessons, it’s me. And here’s what I’ve learned: Weekly private lessons usually suck. ...
Guitar Is Slipping Away—But It’s Not Your Fault
If you’re feeling like life is overwhelming your music right now—you’re not alone. I hope it’s okay if I speak plainly here. A bit more serious than usual, but I think it's necessary. And if this resonates with you, come join our free community with over 450 supportive guitarists of all ages and backgrounds. Free lessons, support, advice, and just great people. Join When Guitar Isn't Enoug...
The best Guitar Lessons are now Free
I receive hundreds of guitar questions daily. Posture, fretboard visualization, improvisation, intervals—it’s a flood of curiosity. Each topic could fill a lifetime of study. But we only get one lifetime to do it all. How can we make every hour of practice count? The Free Course A few years back, I bundled all those recurring questions into one course I called The Teach Yourself Course. It quic...

Life Long Guitarist

A newsletter for mature guitarists seeking long-term musical growth.
Footer Logo
About Login

Join the LifeLong Guitarist Newsletter

I'll NEVER Send You Spam. Only Awesome FREE lessons.